Consulteth Consulteth Inspiration For Your Lamp

In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines

Global Warming:In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines2

By Alphonsine Mousseau. Global Warming. Published at Friday, February 01st, 2019 - 00:44:46 AM.

The proposed Mountain Valley Pipeline would carve a 150-foot-wide swath through the Appalachian Mountains, including a several-mile stretch tracking and then crossing the Appalachian Trail — the revered 2,168-mile hiking route that extends from Georgia to Maine. The threat to the bucolic nature of that trail (even though it already crosses roadways about every four miles) has drawn a national spotlight to the project, one of a half-dozen pending or approved natural gas pipelines running from Appalachian shale fields to outlets along the East Coast and in the Midwest.

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which recently issued a final environmental impact statement for the Mountain Valley project, needs to ensure that the pipeline, if it goes forward, will be minimally invasive to such beautiful terrain, and have as little impact on the Appalachian Trail as possible. But the bigger question is when and whether such pipelines are necessary, and whether FERC, which must approve all interstate gas pipelines, is up to the task of deciding.

Critics argue that the commission is too cozy with the pipeline industry and too quick with the approval stamp (which is especially galling for landowners who then lose property to pipelines through eminent domain). They say it does not adequately weigh public input and fails to take a broad view of the state of the natural gas supply, as well as its impact on the environment.

In a controversial statement filed as he left FERC earlier this year, former commissioner Norman C. Bay (an Obama appointee) argued that while FERC has been approving pipelines to ship gas from the Marcellus and Utica shale fields in Pennsylvania and West Virginia, it "has never conducted a comprehensive study of the environmental consequences of increased production from that region" in determining the environmental impacts of the pipelines themselves. Such a narrow focus fails, for instance, to account for the amount of methane incidentally released into the atmosphere, which has an exponentially higher short-term impact on global warming than carbon dioxide.

What's more, just because a pipeline's builders can show they have buyers for the gas does not mean the pipeline is necessary; nor does the short-term demand justify infrastructure investment with half-century shelf life. FERC officials say they listen to all sides, and note that the commission lacks the authority to regulate how gas is produced or captured — just how it reaches its market. To be sure, natural gas is a better alternative to higher-polluting coal in generating electricity or heating homes (which it long ago supplanted), but gas is still a fossil fuel and the world should be focused on weaning itself as much and as fast as it can to limit the worst effects of global warming.

There are several reform proposals floating around to make FERC more effective. One, introduced by two Virginia Democrats in the Senate and by a West Virginia Republican in the House, would tackle several issues, including requiring more public hearings in more locations along a planned pipeline route. Another proposal is to change the framework for how FERC measures need, requiring it to consider the aggregate impact of pipelines, rather than just taking each application as it comes.

FERC needs a review of what its mission is and whether that mission is being achieved. It seems foolish to weigh the merits of pipeline proposals individually, and without accounting for the entire environmental impact of moving gas to market. In an era of global warming, it's also foolish to expand infrastructure that will serve to hasten climate change, rather than combat it.

Given the "drill, sell, burn" mindset in the White House and Congress, meaningful reform will be hard to achieve — the prevailing philosophy favors less government involvement and the undoing of even efficient regulatory regimens. Still, the effort needs to be made for the sake of the environment's sake, for consumers who could well wind up shouldering the costs of overdeveloped and unnecessary infrastructure, and for investors who would be on the hook if that expensive infrastructure become obsolete as the world moves away from burning fossil fuels.


Gallery of In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines

Global Warming:In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines
Global Warming:In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines1

52 of 100, by 105 User Ratings
1 stars 2 stars 3 stars 4 stars 5 stars

Related Global Warming Posts

140 countries will phase out HFCs. What are these and why do they matter.

140 countries will phase out HFCs. What are these and why do they matter.Jan 22, 2019 | Pascaline Charlesbois

Learning Facts Through Fiction: An Imagined Encounter

Learning Facts Through Fiction: An Imagined EncounterJan 31, 2019 | Pascaline Charlesbois

Conservative Charities Fueled Trump’s Exit From Paris Climate Accord

Conservative Charities Fueled Trump’s Exit From Paris Climate AccordJan 22, 2019 | Alphonsine Mousseau

Global warming is mostly man-made, but why?

Global warming is mostly man-made, but why?Jan 08, 2019 | Pascaline Charlesbois
Bomb cyclones, polar vortexes – global warming in winter
Bomb cyclones, polar vortexes – global warming in winterJan 08, 2019 | Pascaline Charlesbois
Scientists Cast Doubt On An Apparent ‘Hiatus’ In Global Warming
Scientists Cast Doubt On An Apparent ‘Hiatus’ In Global WarmingJan 24, 2019 | Pascaline Charlesbois


Gallery of In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines

Global Warming:In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas PipelinesGlobal Warming:In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines1Global Warming:In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines2

Comments of In The Age Of Global Warming, Do We Really Need So Many New Natural Gas Pipelines


Today's Most Viewed Global Warming Ideas

Global warming leads to intense hurricanes

Global warming leads to intense hurricanesJan 08, 2019 | Pascaline Charlesbois

Letters: Annapolis needs to revamp its planning process; healthy soil can help counter global warming

Letters: Annapolis needs to revamp its planning process; healthy soil can help counter global warmingJan 08, 2019 | Pascaline Charlesbois

Scientists Find Some Hope for Coral Reefs: The Strong May Survive

Scientists Find Some Hope for Coral Reefs: The Strong May SurviveJan 10, 2019 | Alphonsine Mousseau

In the age of global warming, do we really need so many new natural gas pipelines

In the age of global warming, do we really need so many new natural gas pipelinesFeb 01, 2019 | Alphonsine Mousseau
140 countries will phase out HFCs. What are these and why do they matter.
140 countries will phase out HFCs. What are these and why do they matter.Jan 22, 2019 | Pascaline Charlesbois
Scientists Cast Doubt On An Apparent ‘Hiatus’ In Global Warming
Scientists Cast Doubt On An Apparent ‘Hiatus’ In Global WarmingJan 24, 2019 | Pascaline Charlesbois

Categories

Fresh Posts

Archives

Pages

Tag Cloud

About Contact Terms of Service Privacy Policy Cookie Policy Copyright Sitemap

Any content, trademark’s, or other material that might be found on the Consulteth website that is not Consulteth’s property remains the copyright of its respective owner/s. In no way does Consulteth claim ownership or responsibility for such items, and you should seek legal consent for any use of such materials from its owner.